Cities ranked on a weighted mix of school quality, safety, affordability, outdoor access, and community programming.
If you are moving to the Greater Memphis area with kids in tow, the choice of city matters more here than in almost any other metro in Tennessee. The suburbs ringing Memphis sit within a single county — Shelby — plus adjacent Fayette and Tipton counties, and the differences between them are not subtle. School quality, crime patterns, home prices, and the presence of organized community life vary dramatically from one city to the next, sometimes across a single county line. What you get in exchange for a longer commute into Memphis can be a genuinely different environment for raising a family.
The cities on this list stretch from a major urban center with unbeatable affordability to quiet exurban towns where prices rival Nashville suburbs. The strongest schools tend to cluster in communities with independent school districts — places that set their own curriculum and staffing — while affordability improves as you move farther from the I-40 and I-240 corridors. Safety is a genuine differentiator here: some smaller towns post crime figures well below state averages, while others carry risk that families should look at carefully before committing. The sections below walk through each city's real trade-offs for parents with school-age children.
Each city is scored 1-10 on every dimension below against a fixed statewide scale — never against the other cities in this region — then combined into one weighted Composite score out of 10.
Ranked by overall composite score. Click any city to jump to the full breakdown.
| # | City | Composite | Schools | Safety | Median Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Arlington Shelby County | 7.4/10 | 10 | 8 | $407,320 |
| 2 | Germantown Shelby County | 7.2/10 | 10 | 8 | $485,907 |
| 3 | Bartlett Shelby County | 7.2/10 | 8 | 8 | $320,892 |
| 4 | Memphis Shelby County | 7.0/10 | 4 | 8 | $145,335 |
| 5 | Lakeland Shelby County | 6.9/10 | 10 | 8 | $448,503 |
| 6 | Collierville Shelby County | 6.9/10 | 10 | 8 | $505,746 |
| 7 | Millington Shelby County | 6.6/10 | 6 | 2 | $239,609 |
| 8 | Oakland Fayette County | 6.1/10 | 4 | 10 | $352,101 |
| 9 | Atoka Tipton County | 5.8/10 | 6 | 8 | $350,873 |
| 10 | Somerville Fayette County | 4.9/10 | 4 | 4 | $295,420 |
| 11 | Piperton Fayette County | 4.7/10 | 4 | 8 | $672,372 |
#1 Top Overall · Shelby County
Best for families who want top-tier schools in a small-city setting.
Arlington's strongest card is its schools — Arlington Community Schools draws families from across Shelby County who want a district with real academic momentum in a small-city setting. The community calendar keeps residents genuinely engaged, with a farmers market and recurring festivals that give the town a cohesive identity. A typical home here comes in at $407,320, which reflects the demand that school quality and low crime together create. Herb Parsons Lake and local greenways cover the basics for outdoor life, though you won't find the kind of trail network that defines more recreation-focused communities.
Arlington suits families who put school district above all else and want a small-city feel with enough community events to feel rooted. It sits closer in character to Bartlett than to Collierville — more grounded and less resort-like, with prices that reflect genuine demand rather than luxury positioning.
#2 Top Schools · Shelby County
Best for families who want polished suburban life with excellent schools.
Germantown has built its identity around a combination of strong schools, low crime, and a walkable historic town center that gives it a residential completeness rare in suburban Memphis. The school district draws consistent praise, and violent crime figures are among the lowest in the state for a city of its size. Families pay for that combination: a typical home runs $485,907, which prices out buyers who need room in the budget. The greenways and trail network are genuinely usable, and community anchors like the Germantown Festival and Horse Show give the calendar real texture.
Germantown tends to suit families where both parents are working professional incomes and school quality is non-negotiable. It is a more polished, amenity-rich environment than Arlington — less of a small-town feel and more of a fully-realized suburb.
Looking to buy in Greater Memphis? Estimate your payment.
Enter your numbers to see an estimated monthly mortgage payment.
Estimate only. Excludes HOA fees and mortgage insurance. The interest rate above is a starting point, not a quoted rate — replace it with your own to see real numbers. Insurance is a flat placeholder, not a Greater Memphis quote.
Tax laws, local municipal fees, and utility costs change frequently and individual situations vary. This page is general information, not tax or legal advice — always consult a qualified tax professional, CPA, or local municipal offices for personalized guidance.
#3 Practical Family Suburb · Shelby County
Best for families balancing strong schools with a realistic budget.
Bartlett brings together strong schools, solid safety numbers, and a home price of $320,892 that leaves enough room in the budget for the rest of life. Bartlett City Schools carry a strong rating that places them well above most Tennessee suburban districts. Proximity to Shelby Farms gives families outdoor access that punches above the city's size, and the community calendar, while not as dense as Memphis proper, covers the seasonal basics.
Bartlett is a genuinely strong fit for families who want good schools and low crime without stretching into the premium pricing of Germantown or Collierville. It has more of an established, lived-in suburban character than newer developments farther east — which is exactly what many families moving from a larger city are looking for.
#4 Top Affordability · Shelby County
Best for budget-conscious families who value urban energy and outdoor access.
Memphis is the city that surprises most people doing this comparison. The school district's rating trails the suburban independents, but on safety, outdoor access, and community programming, the city holds its own — Shelby Farms is one of the largest urban parks in the country, the Mississippi River greenways are genuine, and a community calendar anchored by Memphis in May and a world-famous barbecue competition gives residents more organized civic life than almost any suburb on this list. The home price tells the starkest story: a typical home is $145,335, which opens the door for families who would be priced out of every other city here.
Memphis suits families who can do their homework on school boundaries — private options, charter schools, and specific attendance zones vary widely — and who value affordability and urban energy over a manicured suburb. It is a fundamentally different trade-off than the Shelby County suburbs, not a lesser one.
#5 Top Schools · Shelby County
Best for families prioritizing schools and safety in a quiet enclave.
Lakeland combines excellent schools and strong safety figures with a home price of $448,503 — a premium that reflects what families are willing to pay for both. Garner Lake and nearby Meeman-Shelby Forest State Park give outdoor-minded families more than the typical suburban option. The honest gap in Lakeland's profile is organized community programming: unlike Arlington or Bartlett, the city has very little in the way of recurring events, farmers markets, or festivals, which can make it feel quieter and less socially connected for families still building roots.
Lakeland is a strong fit for families who prioritize schools and safety and are comfortable building their social life outside city-organized programming. It feels more like a residential enclave than a town with its own civic pulse — worth understanding before you commit.
#6 Top Schools · Shelby County
Best for families who want a town square and an elite school district.
Collierville carries a home price of $505,746, driven by resort-town-adjacent demand and the pull of an independent school district that consistently earns recognition as one of Tennessee's strongest. Safety figures are low across the board. The Wolf River greenway and Herb Parsons Lake provide outdoor access, and the town square gives Collierville a genuine downtown anchor that most Memphis suburbs lack. The community events calendar is lighter than the price point might suggest — Fair on the Square and the Symphony concerts are pleasant, but families looking for a dense calendar of organized activity will need to supplement.
Collierville tends to suit families who want an elite school district and are drawn to a town-square aesthetic — and who have the budget to support it. It is a quieter, more polished environment than Bartlett, with a stronger sense of its own identity than Lakeland.
#7 Top Affordability · Shelby County
Best for outdoor-loving families who need an accessible entry point.
Millington offers a home price of $239,609 that makes it a genuinely accessible entry point in the Greater Memphis area for families on a tighter budget. The outdoor access is a genuine strength — Meeman-Shelby Forest and the Mississippi River bluffs offer varied recreation that goes well beyond what most small Tennessee cities provide. The community calendar is active, driven by farmers markets and recurring local events. The real caution for families is property crime, which runs noticeably above state norms and is worth investigating at the neighborhood level before committing.
Millington suits budget-conscious families who value outdoor recreation and community life and are willing to do their due diligence on specific streets and blocks rather than treating the whole city as uniformly safe. It has more civic energy than its size would suggest.
#8 Top Safety · Fayette County
Best for families drawn to rural safety and a slower Fayette County pace.
Oakland sits in Fayette County rather than Shelby, which puts it on a different school system than the independent suburban districts — one worth researching carefully if you have school-age children, as it trails state averages. The safety picture is genuinely excellent: violent and property crime figures are well below Tennessee norms, a real strength for families. At $352,101, homes are priced above the budget-friendly tier, making the school trade-off more significant for families who need both value and a strong district.
Oakland tends to suit families who are drawn by the rural pace and exceptional safety of Fayette County and either plan to use private schooling or have children past school age. It is a notably quieter and more agricultural environment than the Shelby County suburbs.
#9 Quiet Tipton County Exurb · Tipton County
Best for families wanting a safe, quiet exurban setting north of Memphis.
Atoka sits in Tipton County, north of Shelby, with a school district that earns a competent mid-range rating — fine for many families, but not the draw that Arlington or Bartlett represent. Safety is a genuine strength: crime figures run well below state and national averages. A home in Atoka typically comes in at $350,873, which is a meaningful investment for a city where schools and organized community life are limited. The organized community programming is very thin, which can make the transition harder for families arriving without a built-in social network.
Atoka suits families who work or travel north of Memphis and want a safe, quiet exurban setting without the premium of Shelby County suburbs. The trade-off is thin civic infrastructure — no farmers markets, few recurring events — so families who need a city to do some of the community-building work for them may find it isolating.
#10 Small Town County Seat · Fayette County
Best for families choosing small-town life over suburban amenities.
Somerville is the county seat of Fayette County, with a slower, more rural pace than any of the Shelby County suburbs and a home price of $295,420 that reflects both the affordability and the distance from Memphis's job centers. Schools trail state averages, and safety is mixed — violent crime is elevated relative to the other smaller towns on this list. Herb Parsons Lake and the surrounding rural land give outdoor-minded families something real to work with.
Somerville suits families who are deliberately choosing a small-town, slower-paced life and are less dependent on a strong school district — remote workers, retirees with grandchildren nearby, or families committed to private schooling. It is not a natural fit for families who need both schools and safety to be strong.
#11 Estate Country Setting · Fayette County
Best for buyers who want privacy and low crime above everything else.
Piperton is a small Fayette County town with a home price of $672,372 — driven by large-lot estate development rather than proximity to urban amenities or a high-performing independent school district. The schools serve the broader Fayette County system, which trails state averages, creating a real mismatch between the price point and school quality that families should think through carefully. Safety is a genuine positive: violent and property crime figures are low. Community programming is thin in Piperton itself, with most organized activity happening in neighboring Collierville.
Piperton tends to suit buyers who want privacy, space, and low crime above all else — and who either have children in private school or are past that stage of life. Families weighing it against Collierville or Germantown will find the school comparison difficult to resolve in Piperton's favor.
A strong family fit in Greater Memphis depends on whether you weight schools and safety above price, or need room in the budget to actually live comfortably. Several suburbs offer exceptional schools and low crime at a cost — while Memphis itself delivers unmatched affordability and outdoor access that surprises most newcomers.
Tell us what you need help with and we'll connect you with local resources.